Senator Rand Paul made waves for recent comments he made regarding the use of drones on an episode of Cavuto the other day.
Paul: “I’ve never argued against any technology being used when you have an imminent threat, an active crime going on,” Paul said. “If someone comes out of a liquor store with a weapon and fifty dollars in cash. I don’t care if a drone kills him or a policeman kills him.”
This sounds like a complete 180 degree flip of his position he argued when he took to the Senate floor for a 13 hour filibuster against the assassination of American citizens on US soil. But it appears the Senator misspoke and offered a bad analogy when explaining just which cases where it would be ethical to use a drone on the homeland. Judge Andrew Napolitano took to the airwaves this morning to explain to Stuart Varney how the Senators position hasn’t shifted at all.
Judge Napolitano: The filibuster was about the concept of targeted assassinations, about the president picking and choosing who to kill in the U.S. or elsewhere who have not received due process of law,” the judge explained. “They have not been charged of a crime, they have not been convicted of a crime, they’ve just gotten in the president’s crosshairs. That is the essence of the filibuster.” He probably should have said ‘Coming out of a liquor store shooting and with 50 bucks.’ If someone is using a deadly weapon on police or the civilians, the police can use a deadly weapon with which to repel that person.”
So in essence the argument is whether or not a life is in imminent danger. It would be violation of due process for a drone to be sent to kill someone, regardless if a warrant has been issued for their arrest. This is because a drone, unlike an officer, cannot be in imminent danger. It is nothing more than a piece of plastic. However, if a situation were to arise where a robber were to be shooting at innocent human beings then it would not make much of a difference what tool was used to subdue the criminal. Someone attempting to take life can be shot with a gun or with any other weapon in order to protect innocent life.
Judge Napolitano fears what every liberty lover should fear, the proliferation of public AND private drones that would lead to massive privacy concerns and fears of abuse. He lays down the ethical and legal framework under which drones could be used domestically, but he also addresses the value issue. Do we want drones all over the place? No, but if we do then Judge Napolitano argues that we absolutely need a warrant if the government wants to use one.
Unmanned aerial vehicles have been around for decades. They have only become controversial in recent years because they have proliferated to a great extent and are used by politicians to perform unconstitutional assassinations of American citizens without due process.
Varney argued that the argument of gun control should be expanded to the concept of drone control. The Judge explained that the government should not have the power to do anything that private citizens do not have the power to do. He believes that if the government owns drones, then citizens should as well. This position comes from the idea that government governs with the consent of the governed and must be held to its own standards. Napolitano argues that we need a judicial authorization for the government to be able to “fly pieces of plastic in our faces” and if he were to decide on that question he would say “it doesn’t.”
Senator Rand Paul was right to filibuster against the unconstitutional use of drones in violation of due process. However he has never claimed to be against the technology itself. People who argue for the outright banning of drones forget that the government never bans something for itself. If the state has drones, so should the citizens.
Senator Paul clarified his statement this morning issuing a press release stating:
Paul: “My comments last night left the mistaken impression that my position on drones had changed. Let me be clear: it has not. Armed drones should not be used in normal crime situations. They only may only be considered in extraordinary, lethal situations where there is an ongoing, imminent threat. I described that scenario previously during my Senate filibuster. Additionally, surveillance drones should only be used with warrants and specific targets. Fighting terrorism and capturing terrorists must be done while preserving our constitutional protections. This was demonstrated last week in Boston. As we all seek to prevent future tragedies, we must continue to bear this in mind.”
Judge Napolitano’s appearance on Varney & Co provided by Mediaite (4:30)
So what do you think? Leave your thoughts below.
[socialpoll id=”[socialpoll id=”7146″]
94 comments
vpn ایفون
Hi would you mind letting me know which webhost you’re using? I’ve loaded your blog in three completely distinct browsers and I must say this site loads a lot quicker then most. Can you suggest a very good hosting company at a trustworthy value? Kudos,…
vpn ایفون
I absolutely adore your weblog and discover a good deal of your post’s to be precisely I’m hunting for. Does one particular supply guest writers to create content offered for you? I would not thoughts producing a submit or elaborating on a handful of o…
vpn ایفون
Proper now it appears like Movable Variety is the leading running a blog platform out there proper now. (from what I have read) Is that what you are utilizing on your weblog?
هیتر
Thanks for yet another educational web internet site. The location else could I get that variety of information composed in this sort of an best strategy?I have a venture that I’m just now running on, and I have been at the search outfor these kinds of…
vpn ایفون
I’m truly loving the theme/design of your internet internet site. Do you ever run into any internet browser compatibility issues? A little amount of my blog audience have complained about my weblog not doing work properly in Explorer but looks excellen…
vpn ایفون
Do you have a spam issue on this website I also am a blogger, and I was curious about your circumstance many of us have developed some good methods and we are seeking to trade strategies with other individuals, why not shoot me an e-mail if interested.
vpn ایفون
Examine under, are some totally unrelated internet-sites to ours, nevertheless, they’re most reputable resources that we use.
vpn ایفون
the time to research or get a look at the content material or world wide web-sites we have linked to below the
دوربین
Excellent put up! We will be linking to this fantastic put up on our web site. Keep up the very good creating.
vpn ایفون
generally posts some amazingly intriguing stuff like this. If youre new to this website
vpn ایفون
remember to pay a visit to the web sites we stick to, such as this one particular particular, as it represents our picks through the world wide web
سی سی کم
Thank you for some other fantastic post. The place else may just anyone get that type of details in these kinds of an best implies of writing? I have a presentation up coming 7 days, and I am on the research for such data.
vpn ایفون
Greetings from Colorado! I’m bored to loss of life at work so I decided to look through your website on my iphone during lunch crack. I actually like the details you offer here and can’t wait around to take a seem when I get residence. I’m shocked at h…
vpn ایفون
What’s up it’s me, I am also visiting this web site on a standard foundation, this internet site is actually pleasurable and the viewers are actually sharing great ideas.
vpn ایفون
underneath you will come across the website link to some web-internet sites that we consider it is very best to check out
خودرو
Thank you for some other fantastic report. The place else might just any person get that sort of information in this kind of an perfect means of writing? I’ve a presentation next 7 days, and I am on the search for these kinds of details.
دوربین
I was curious if you at any time considered of altering the layout of your internet site? Its extremely nicely written I enjoy what youve received to say. But maybe you could a tiny much more in the way of articles so individuals could connect with it…
هیتر
Right here are many of the internet web sites we recommend for our site visitors
vpn ایفون
right here are some hyperlinks to world wide web internet pages that we website link to for the cause that we feel they may be actually really worth visiting
vpn ایفون
Create much more, thats all I have to say. Virtually, it seems as even though you relied on the video clip to make your stage. You obviously know what youre talking about, why waste your intelligence on just posting films to your website when you could…
vpn ایفون
right here are some links to internet webpages that we hyperlink to considering that we feel they are truly really worth checking out
دوربین
Greetings from Florida! I’m bored to demise at work so I made a decision to check out your web site on my iphone throughout lunch crack. I appreciate the details you give right here and can’t wait to just take a search when I get property. I’m shocked…
vpn ایفون
Verify under, are some entirely unrelated internet-websites to ours, however, they’re most reliable resources that we use.
vpn ایفون
Good submit! We will be linking to this fantastic post on our internet site. Keep up the good composing.
vpn ایفون
Hi would you brain stating which blog platform you are working with? I’m organizing to commence my possess weblog shortly but I’m having a tough time deciding between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The explanation I question is due to the…
vpn ایفون
Hello there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Seo? I’m striving to get my website to rank for some qualified key phrases but I’m not observing really good gains. If you know of any remember to share. Many thanks!
vpn ایفون
Hey there! I just lately noticed your internet site and I definitely take pleasure in it. I enjoy to talk about omega xl sometimes. Great to be around, thanks a great deal!
vpn ایفون
What’s up it’s me, I am also visiting this site on a regular foundation, this web site is actually enjoyable and the viewers are actually sharing great views.
vpn ایفون
we came throughout a awesome website that you just could potentially delight in. Consider a search in circumstance you want
vpn ایفون
If you are likely for most superb contents like myself, just go to see this web site everyday due to the fact it provides attribute contents, many thanks
vpn ایفون
Hey there! I just lately saw your web site and I surely appreciate it. I enjoy to talk about omega xl occasionally. Very good to be about, many thanks a lot!
vpn ایفون
Sohan is also getting accused of leaving the jurisdiction in December final year with no authorization.
vpn ایفون
Admiring the commitment you place into your blog and in depth information you offer you. It’s amazing to occur throughout a website each when in a even though that isn’t the same previous rehashed information. Excellent study! I’ve bookmarked your webs…
vpn ایفون
Check underneath, are some completely unrelated world wide web-web sites to ours, nevertheless, they’re most reputable resources that we use.
vpn ایفون
Thanks once more for the website put up.Genuinely thank you! Wonderful.
vpn ایفون
Greetings from Colorado! I’m bored to loss of life at function so I decided to look through your website on my apple iphone in the course of lunch split. I really like the info you supply below and simply cannot wait to get a search when I get property…
vpn ایفون
Hiya! Fast query that’s completely off subject. Do you know how to make your site mobile pleasant? My website seems strange when viewing from my apple apple iphone. I’m striving to discover a theme or plugin that might be in a position to right this co…
vpn ایفون
Right here are a number of of the net web sites we recommend for our site visitors
vpn ایفون
Wonderful site! I discovered it while searching on Yahoo Information. Do you have any ideas on how to get shown in Yahoo News? I have been striving for a while but I in no way seem to be to get there! Thank you
vpn ایفون
The info pointed out inside the report are some of the most successful accessible.
vpn ایفون
My developer is striving to persuade me to transfer to .internet from PHP. I have constantly disliked the idea because of the costs. But he’s tryiong none the significantly less. I have been utilizing Movable-sort on a quantity of sites for about a 12…
vpn ایفون
Many thanks once again for the weblog submit.Actually thank you! Excellent.
vpn ایفون
I’m really taking pleasure in the design and style and structure of your site. It’s a really effortless on the eyes which can make it considerably far more pleasurable for me to come listed here and go to far more frequently. Did you employ the service…
vpn ایفون
here are some hyperlinks to sites that we link to considering that we think they’re worth visiting
vpn ایفون
Hello there colleagues, how is all, and what you desire for to say about this submit, in my view its really incredible made for me.
دوربین
We absolutely really like your site and locate practically all of your post’s to be what exactly I’m looking for. Does 1 provide guest writers to publish material for you? I wouldn’t thoughts writing a put up or elaborating on a good deal of the topics…
vpn ایفون
Just beneath, are a great deal of completely not connected web websites to ours, nonetheless, they could be absolutely actually well worth heading more than.
دوربین
Superb story, reckoned we could mix a number of unrelated info, nevertheless really really worth using a lookup, whoa did one particular grasp about Mid East has acquired a good deal more problerms also
vpn ایفون
I totally really like your website and discover a whole lot of your post’s to be specifically I’m searching for. Does one particular provide guest writers to compose material available for you? I would not mind making a publish or elaborating on a hand…
vpn ایفون
we came across a cool web site that you just could potentially delight in. Just take a appear in circumstance you want
هیتر
Thanks again for the site publish.Actually thank you! Fantastic.
مه پاش
Superb website! I discovered it whilst surfing close to on Yahoo News. Do you have any suggestions on how to get shown in Yahoo News? I have been making an attempt for a while but I never seem to be to get there! Cheers
vpn ایفون
I do not know if it is just me or if probably everyone else encountering issues with your web site. It seems as if some of the composed text inside of your posts are managing off the monitor. Can any individual else you should comment and enable me kno…
vpn ایفون
Check below, are some fully unrelated world wide web-websites to ours, however, they are most dependable sources that we use.
vpn ایفون
Sohan is also getting accused of leaving the jurisdiction in December very last calendar year without having permission.
vpn ایفون
Fantastic website! I found it although surfing all around on Yahoo Information. Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo News? I’ve been striving for a although but I never seem to get there! Cheers
vpn ایفون
Excellent blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A design like yours with a couple of easy adjustements would genuinely make my site stand out. Make sure you allow me know in which you received your style. Bless you
vpn ایفون
I’m genuinely experiencing the style and layout of your weblog. It is a very straightforward on the eyes which helps make it considerably far more nice for me to arrive here and go to far more typically. Did you employ out a developer to produce your c…
vpn ایفون
I absolutely enjoy your site and uncover a lot of your post’s to be just I’m looking for. Does 1 offer guest writers to compose content accessible for you? I wouldn’t mind producing a post or elaborating on a few of the topics you compose in relation t…
vpn ایفون
Thanks once again for the website submit.Really thank you! Fantastic.
vpn ایفون
Admiring the devotion you set into your weblog and in depth info you provide. It is wonderful to come across a website each when in a while that isn’t the identical aged rehashed data. Fantastic read through! I have bookmarked your internet site and I’…
vpn ایفون
Right now it appears like Movable Kind is the top running a blog system out there right now. (from what I have study) Is that what you are employing on your website?
vpn ایفون
I do not know if it is just me or if possibly everyone else encountering issues with your internet site. It seems as if some of the prepared text inside of your posts are working off the display. Can somebody else remember to comment and permit me know…
vpn ایفون
Examine underneath, are some fully unrelated net-sites to ours, however, they are most reliable sources that we use.
vpn ایفون
Admiring the dedication you put into your website and in depth data you supply. It is amazing to arrive throughout a site each once in a although that isn’t the very same previous rehashed info. Fantastic go through! I have bookmarked your web site and…
کابینت
here are some hyperlinks to internet webpages that we website link to for the cause that we think they could be genuinely value browsing
vpn ایفون
Hi would you mind stating which site platform you are doing work with? I’m preparing to commence my very own blog before long but I’m possessing a challenging time choosing between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The explanation I question…
مه پاش
Here are a number of of the net websites we advise for our guests
vpn ایفون
I’m truly making the most of the style and format of your blog. It’s a very effortless on the eyes which helps make it a lot much more nice for me to occur listed here and check out far more typically. Did you employ out a developer to create your conc…
هیتر
Appreciating the time and hard work you put into your site and comprehensive info you supply. It is fantastic to arrive across a site each after in a while that is not the identical undesired rehashed details. Superb read! I’ve saved your web site and…
vpn ایفون
Appreciating the time and effort you place into your website and comprehensive details you offer. It is excellent to appear across a website each once in a even though that is not the same unwanted rehashed data. Fantastic study! I have saved your site…
اسکوتر
I do not know if it is just me or if maybe everyone else encountering troubles with your site. It appears as if some of the composed textual content inside of your posts are managing off the monitor. Can any person else please comment and let me know i…
اسکوتر
Wonderful blog! I identified it although browsing close to on Yahoo Information. Do you have any ideas on how to get shown in Yahoo Information? I have been striving for a whilst but I in no way look to get there! Cheers
vpn ایفون
Sohan is also getting accused of leaving the jurisdiction in December previous yr without permission.
vpn ایفون
Just beneath, are a whole lot of entirely not connected web websites to ours, however, they could be certainly genuinely worth going in excess of.
اسکوتر
Right here are a number of of the web websites we recommend for our visitors
اسکوتر
Hi there colleagues, how is all, and what you would like for to say about this put up, in my check out its truly amazing developed for me.
اسکوتر
remember to pay a visit to the sites we stick to, this sort of as this one distinct, as it signifies our picks through the web
vpn ایفون
Thanks once more for the blog post.Actually thank you! Excellent.
اسکوتر
Howdy just needed to give you a quick heads up and permit you know a handful of of the images aren’t loading appropriately. I’m not confident why but I consider its a linking issue. I’ve tried out it in two distinct world wide web browsers and each pre…
اسکوتر
even though internet sites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we truly feel they are truly truly really worth a go through, so have a search
اسکوتر
Fairly! This has been a truly great report. Thanks for offering this data.
vpn ایفون
It is likely to be end of mine day, nonetheless prior to finish I am reading this superb publish to enhance my encounter.
دوربین
With regard to ergonomics and the innovative technilogy Heuer replica watches have been the great samples of sports activities watches.
دوربین
under you will come across the url to some world wide web-websites that we contemplate it is greatest to visit
اسکوتر
Do you have a spam dilemma on this site I also am a blogger, and I was wanting to know your predicament we have developed some great methods and we are seeking to swap methods with other folks, be positive to shoot me an electronic mail if fascinated.
اسکوتر
Superb tale, reckoned we could blend a number of unrelated information, even so genuinely truly value having a search, whoa did one particular master about Mid East has obtained a great deal more problerms also
دوربین
Do you have a spam issue on this blog I also am a blogger, and I was curious about your situation a lot of of us have developed some good techniques and we are searching to trade techniques with others, why not shoot me an e-mail if intrigued.
دوربین
below you will occur throughout the website link to some internet-sites that we take into account it is greatest to check out
vpn ایفون
under you will appear across the hyperlink to some internet-websites that we think about it is ideal to visit
اسکوتر
typically posts some amazingly intriguing things like this. If youre new to this internet site
اسکوتر
When I at first commented I clicked the “Notify me when new responses are added” checkbox and now every single time a remark is added I get a few email messages with the same remark. Is there any way you can eliminate me from that support? Thank you!
وی پی ان
here are some backlinks to net internet pages that we link to given that we really feel they are actually well worth going to
اسکوتر
Hey! I know this is relatively off subject but I was asking yourself which weblog system are you making use of for this web site? I’m receiving sick and exhausted of WordPress simply because I’ve experienced issues with hackers and I’m looking at choic…